1952 RABL Retro Season All Stars |
First Team |
 Roy Campanella C
 |  Mickey Vernon 1B
 |  Red Schoendienst 2B
 |  Eddie Matthews 3B
 |  Alvin Dark SS
 |  Duke Snider OF
 |  Stan Musial OF
 |  Ralph Kiner OF
 |  Warren Spahn P
 |
Second Team |
 Yogi Berra
C
 |  Ted Kluszewski 1B
 |  Granny Hamner 2B
 |  Al Rosen 3B
 |  Pee-Wee Reese SS
 |  Vic Wertz OF
 |  Larry Doby OF
 |  Gus Bell OF
 |  Billy Pierce P
 |
American League | MVPs | National League |
 Roy Campanella .281/.350/.594 28 DOs 49 HRs 107 Runs 156 RBI 16 GWRBI 152 OPS+
 | |  Al Rosen .328/.407/.587 41 HRs 118 Runs 139 RBI 11 GWRBI 168 OPS+
 |
American League | Cy Youngs | National League |
 Billy Pierce 23-8, 2 shutouts, 14 CG, 209 Ks 2.62 ERA 1.122 WHIP
 | |  Warren Spahn 21-9, 2 shutouts, 22 CG, 2 Saves 1.108 WHIP, 2.47 ERA
 |
1952 RABL Retro Season All Stars |
First Team |
 Yogi Berra
C
 |  Ted Kluszewski 1B
 |  Red Schoendienst 2B
 |  Al Rosen 3B
 |  Alvin Dark SS
 |  Stan Musial OF
 |  Larry Doby OF
 |  Mickey Mantle OF
 |  Robin Roberts P
 |
Second Team |
 Roy Campanella C
 |  Luke Easter 1B
 |  Jackie Robinson 2B
 |  Sid Gordon 3B
 |  Phil Rizzuto SS
 |  Hank Sauer OF
 |  Andy Pafko OF
 |  Vic Wertz OF
 |  Billy Pierce P
 |
American League | MVPs | National League |
 Ted Kluszewski .341/.392/.608 17 TRs 23 HRs 95 Runs 103 RBI 18 GWRBI 175 OPS+
 | |  Stan Musial .335/.427/.507 21 HRs 117 Runs 92 RBI 95 BBs 12 GWRBI 172 OPS+
 |
American League | Cy Youngs | National League |
 Billy Pierce 17-9, 2 shutouts, 156 Ks 2.04 ERA 1.128 WHIP
 | |  Robin Roberts 20-10, 5 shutouts, 24 CGs 1.000 WHIP, 2.39 ERA
 |
1951 RABL Retro Season All Stars |
First Team |
 Roy Campanella C
 |  Gil Hodgs 1B
 |  Jackie Robinson 2B
 |  Willie Jones 3B
 |  Alvin Dark SS
 |  Monte Irvin OF
 |  Stan Musial OF
 |  Hank Sauer OF
 |  Warren Spahn P
 |
Second Team |
 Yogi Berra
C
 |  Eddie Robinson 1B
 |  Jerry Priddy 2B
 |  Randy Jackson 3B
 |  Pee-Wee Reese SS
 |  Ralph Kiner OF
 |  Bobby Thomson OF
 |  Sid Gordon OF
 |  Mike Garcia P
 |
American League | MVPs | National League |
 Gil Hodges .290/.385/.617 51 HRs 117 Runs 154 RBI 12 GWRBI 139 OPS+
 | |  Monte Irvin .356/.435/.576 29 HRs 131 Runs 104 RBI 11 Triples 161 OPS+
 |
American League | Cy Youngs | National League |
 Mickey McDermott 11-5, 3 shutouts, 4 Saves 3.19 ERA
 | |  Warren Spahn 26-7, 3 shutouts, 1.11 WHIP, 3.13 ERA
 |
1950 RABL Retro Season All Stars |
First Team |
 Yogi Berra
C
 |  Walt Dropo 1B
 |  Bobby Doerr 2B
 |  Bob Elliot 3B
 |  Granny Hamner SS
 |  Del Ennis OF
 |  Joe DiMaggio OF
 |  Sid Gordon OF
 |  Early Wynn P
 |
Second Team |
 Roy Campanella C
 |  Earl Torgeson 1B
 |  Jerry Priddy 2B
 |  Al Rosen 3B
 |  Phil Rizzuto SS
 |  Vic Wertz OF
 |  Ralph Kiner OF
 |  Larry Doby OF
 |  Jim Hearn P
 |
American League | MVPs | National League |
 Joe DiMaggio .294/.371/.602 40 HRs 111 Runs 173 RBI 10 GWRBI
 | |  Del Ennis .382/.453/.678 44 HRs 134 Runs 166 RBI Triple Crown
 |
American League | Cy Youngs | National League |
 Johnny Sain 26-8, 3 shutouts, 3.54 ERA
 | |  Early Wynn 21-4, 4 shutouts, 4 Saves, 2.00 ERA
 |