| Year |
League/Division |
Team
Name |
Stadium |
Record |
Division/Finish |
Manager |
1st Draft
Pick |
| 2012 |
NL Central |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
PNC |
69-93 |
3rd NL Central
|
Bob Krofcheck |
Jose Reyes
#1/15 |
| 2013 |
NL Central |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
PNC |
90-72
|
2nd NL Central
(Won Wildcard Series over Rockies 4 games to 1;
Won Divisional Series over Cardinals 4 games to 3; NLCS lost to Philadelphia 4 games to 3)
|
Bob Krofcheck |
Yu Darvish
#1/4 |
| 2014 |
NL Central |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
PNC |
108-54
|
1st NL Central
(Won
Divisional Series over Rockies 4 games to 2;won NLCS over Nationals 4
games to 1; lost World Series to Red Sox 4 games to 3) |
Bob Krofcheck |
Sonny Gray
#1/21 |
| 2015 |
NL Central |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
PNC |
105-57
|
1st NL Central
(Won Divisional Series over Marlins 4 games to 2;won NLCS over Braves 4 games to 1; lost World Series to Orioles 4 games to 3) |
Bob Krofcheck |
Ken Giles
#1/23 |
| 2016 |
NL Central |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
PNC |
102-60 |
2nd NL Central
(Won Wildcard Series over Cardinals 4 games to 3; Lost Divisional Series to Mets 4 games to 2) |
Bob Krofcheck |
Carson Smith
#1/23 |
| 2017 | NL Central | Pittsburgh Pirates | PNC | 75-83 | 4th NL Central
| Bob Krofcheck | 
Dylan Bundy
#1/19 |
2018
| NL Central | Pittsburgh Pirates | PNC | 102-60 | 1st NL Central
(Won Divisional Series over Cubs 4 games to 2; lost NLCS to Braves 4 games to 0)
| Bob Krofcheck | 
Ozzie Albies
#1/11 |
2019
| NL Central | Pittsburgh Pirates | PNC | 99-63 | 2nd NL Central
(Won Wildcard Series over Cardinals 4 games to 3; Won Divisional Series over Dodgers 4 games to 2; NLCS lost to Philadelphia 4 games to 1)
| Bob Krofcheck | 
Austin Meadows
#1/22 |
| 2020 | NL Central | Milwaukee Brewers | Miller | 101-61 | 2nd NL Central
(Won Wildcard Series over Cardinals 4 games to 0; lost Divisional Series to Mets 4 games to 3) | Bob Krofcheck | 
Luis Arraez
#1/22 |
| 2021 | NL Central | Milwaukee Brewers | Miller | 101-61 | 2nd NL Central
(Lost Wildcard Series to Marlins 4 games to 3)
| Bob Krofcheck | 
Devin Williams
#1/18 |
| 2022 | NL Central | Pittsburgh Pirates | PNC | 95-67 | 3rd NL Central
(Lost Wildcard Series to Cardinals 4 games to 3)
| Bob Krofcheck | 
Shane Baz
#1/16 |
| 2023 | AL East | Tampa Bay Rays | Tropicana | 109-53 | 1st AL East
(Lost Divisional Series to Toronto 4 games to 2) | Bob Krofcheck | 
Justin Verlander
#1/15 |
| 2024 | AL East | Tampa Bay Rays | Tropicana | 91-71 | 2nd AL East
(Defeated Texas in the Wildcard Series 4 games to 1; lost Divisional Series to Toronto 4 games to 2) | Bob Krofcheck | 
Johan Rojas
#1/16 |
| 2025 | AL East | New York Yankees | Yankee Stadium | 92-70 | 3rd AL East
(Lost Wildcard Series to Boston 4 games to 3) | Bob Krofcheck | 
Cade Smith
#1/8 |
| 2026 | AL East | New York Yankees | Yankee Stadium | 0-0 | AL East | Bob Krofcheck | 
Mike Vasil
#2/15 |