| Year |
League/Division |
Team
Name |
Stadium |
Record |
Division/Finish |
Manager |
1st
Round
Pick |
| 2012 |
NL Central |
Cincinnati Reds |
Great American |
87-75 |
1st NL Central
(Lost Divisional Series to LA Dodgers 4 games to 2) |
Sam Alberry |
Joey Votto
#14 |
| 2013 |
NL Central |
Cincinnati Reds |
Great American |
87-76
|
3rd NL Central
(Lost Wildcard tiebreaker game to Washington Nationals)
|
Sam Alberry |
Darren O'Day
#17 |
| 2014 |
NL Central |
Cincinnati Reds |
Great American |
83-80
|
2nd NL Central
(Won Wildcard tiebreaker game vs Cardinals; Lost Wildcard Series to Nationals 4 Games to 1) |
Sam Alberry |
None |
| 2015 |
NL Central |
Cincinnati Reds |
Great American |
83-80
|
4th NL Central
(Lost Wildcard tiebreaker game to Miami Marlins) |
Sam Alberry |
Matt Shoemaker
#13 |
| 2016 |
NL Central |
Cincinnati Reds |
Great American |
91-71 |
4th NL Central
(Won Wildcard over Giants 4 games to 2; Won Divisional Series over Cubs 4 games to 0; Won NLCS over Mets 4 games to 2; Won World Series over Orioles 4 games to 1) |
Sam Alberry |
None |
| 2017 | NL Central | Cincinnati Reds | Great American | 88-75 | 3rd NL Central
(Lost Wildcard tiebreaker game to SF Giants) | Sam Alberry (73-56)
Chris Kaufman (15-19) | 
Tyler Naquin
#24 |
| 2018 | NL Central | Cincinnati Reds | Great American | 76-86 | 4th NL Central | Sam Alberry | 
German Marquez
#12 |
| 2019 | NL Central | Cincinnati Reds | Great American | 0-0 | NL Central | Sam Alberry | 
Max Muncy
#8 |